Carbon & Energy 

Energy Regulation Strategic Plan Evaluation Consultant

Regional Association of Energy Regulators for Eastern and Southern Africa
ZambiaRemote
Source posted Deadline

Assess the regional energy regulators’ 2017–2026 strategy and recommend priorities for its next plan. Independent, virtual short-term assignment lasting four to six weeks.

About the job

Terms of reference

END-TERM REVIEW OF THE RAERESA STRATEGIC PLAN 2017–2026

Brief Description of the Assignment: The expert services expected to be provided by an individual consultant, under this assignment include: (i) an independent end-term review of the performance of the RAERESA Strategic Plan 2017–2026 and its Business Plan 2017–2021; (ii) an assessment of RAERESA’s governance, institutional, organisational and financial arrangements; and (iii) evidence-based lessons and recommendations to inform the development of the new RAERESA Strategic Plan 2027–2031. The review will involve consultations with member regulators, COMESA Member States, regional and continental institutions and development partners, to ensure that the next Plan is aligned with regional energy goals and with RAERESA’s mandate as the energy regulatory institution of COMESA.

  1. INTRODUCTION

  2. The Regional Association of Energy Regulators for Eastern and Southern Africa (RAERESA) is a specialised institution of COMESA, established by its Constitution pursuant to Articles 106 to 109 of the Treaty establishing COMESA. It was launched on 16 March 2009, and its mandate covers all COMESA Member States. Its objectives include capacity building and information sharing, harmonisation of legal and regulatory frameworks, regional energy regulatory cooperation and inter-regional collaboration, with a view to facilitating cross-border energy trade and investment.

  3. RAERESA’s Vision is “to be a centre of excellence for energy regulation and consumer protection in the COMESA Region”, and its Mission is “to promote energy regulation and protect consumer welfare within the COMESA region thereby facilitating regional integration of the energy markets in the COMESA region”. RAERESA is governed by the Plenary, the Executive Committee, the Portfolio Committees and the Secretariat.

  4. The current Strategic Plan 2017–2026 is RAERESA’s second strategic plan. It was developed with the support of the EU Technical Assistance Facility for Sustainable Energy for All (SE4ALL) and validated by the Executive Committee and the Plenary in January 2017. It was operationalised through a Business Plan 2017–2021 and annual Work Programmes. The Plan set out to contribute to increased access to electricity and clean cooking fuels, a larger share of renewable energy in final energy consumption, and improved energy efficiency.

  5. The Strategic Plan is structured around five strategic goals, each with a strategic objective, implementation initiatives and expected outcomes (45 initiatives in total):

  • Strategic Goal 1 – Capacity building, information exchange, energy statistics and database: developed capacities of members and shared information, statistics and data (12 initiatives, including study tours, regional market workshops, utility benchmarking courses, the energy statistics sub-committee and peer reviews);

  • Strategic Goal 2 – Harmonised legal and regulatory frameworks: enhanced integration of energy systems and trade, and enabled energy investments (14 initiatives, including best-practice guidelines on regulator autonomy, licensing, grid codes and market rules, tariffs and transmission pricing, compliance monitoring, and model petroleum, LPG and gas frameworks);

  • Strategic Goal 3 – Enhanced renewable energy: increased share of renewable energy in the energy mix (4 initiatives on RE standards, competitive bidding, biofuels and off-grid electrification);

  • Strategic Goal 4 – Enhanced environment and energy efficiency: promoted energy-efficient technologies and practices (7 initiatives, including EE audits, building codes, testing laboratories, minimum energy performance standards and labelling, and a target to reduce network losses by at least 10%); and

  • Strategic Goal 5 – Efficient and effective Secretariat and RAERESA: an autonomous Secretariat, a long-term funding strategy with transition to self-financing, staffing, governance rules, partnerships, communication and statutory meetings (8 initiatives).

  1. The Plan estimated a resource requirement of approximately US$2–2.5 million per year. Projections for 2017–2021 amounted to US$9.87 million, mainly from the 11th European Development Fund, with membership contributions expected to grow over time. The Plan also approved a restructured governance model with service-based Portfolio Committees and a six-position autonomous Secretariat.

  2. Chapter 7 of the Strategic Plan requires a final evaluation by an independent consultant to review its implementation and draw lessons as inputs into RAERESA’s next strategic planning cycle. With the Plan coming to an end in December 2026, RAERESA has commenced the development of a new Strategic Plan for 2027–2031. This end-term review is the principal input to that process.

  3. The operating environment has changed significantly since 2017. Relevant developments include the African Single Electricity Market (AfSEM) and the Continental Power System Master Plan, the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), Mission 300, progress towards EAPP–SAPP electricity market coupling, the operationalisation of the EAPP Independent Regulatory Board and market operator arrangements, the growth of distributed and off-grid energy solutions, and the proposed COMESA Energy Institute. The review shall therefore assess both past performance and continued relevance.

  4. This assignment will be procured, managed and implemented by the RAERESA Secretariat.

  5. SCOPE OF SERVICES

The Consultant will be required to undertake a comprehensive review covering the following areas:

B1. Objectives and coverage of the review

  1. The overall objective is to provide RAERESA with an independent, evidence-based assessment of what the Strategic Plan 2017–2026 achieved, what it did not achieve and why, to shape the strategic direction, priorities, institutional arrangements and results framework of the Strategic Plan 2027–2031. The specific objectives are to:
  • assess the extent to which the five strategic goals, objectives, implementation initiatives and expected outcomes were achieved, and quantify performance against planned targets;

  • assess the continued relevance of the Vision, Mission, goals and priorities against the needs of members and the changed regional and continental energy landscape;

  • evaluate the efficiency of implementation, including the use of financial and human resources against the Plan’s budget and projections;

  • assess RAERESA’s governance, institutional and organisational arrangements, including the transition to an autonomous Secretariat and the functioning of the Plenary, Executive Committee and Portfolio Committees;

  • assess financial sustainability, including membership contributions, the contribution formula, development partner support and progress towards self-financing;

  • assess the adoption and domestication of RAERESA guidelines, model frameworks and standards by member regulators and Member States, and their effect on regulatory practice and cross-border trade;

  • assess the adequacy of the monitoring, evaluation, reporting and communication systems used to track the Plan; and

  • identify lessons, good practices, unfinished business and emerging issues, and make concrete, prioritised recommendations for the Strategic Plan 2027–2031.

  1. The review shall cover the full implementation period from January 2017 to the latest available data in 2026, including the Business Plan 2017–2021, the annual Work Programmes, all member regulators and associate members, the Secretariat and governance organs, and programmes implemented with partners (including the EDF11-financed regional energy market programme and collaboration with EAPP, SAPP, RERA, EREA, AFUR, AUC and AUDA-NEPAD). It shall cover electricity, petroleum, natural gas and LPG, renewable energy and energy efficiency. Where a mid-term review, technical audits or annual evaluations were undertaken, the Consultant shall build on them.

B2. Evaluation criteria and key questions

  1. The review shall apply the OECD-DAC evaluation criteria. The indicative questions below shall be refined by the Consultant into an evaluation matrix at inception:
CriterionKey evaluation questions
RelevanceDid the goals and initiatives respond to the priorities of members, COMESA and the region? Are the Vision, Mission and guiding principles still fit for purpose? Did the Plan adapt to emerging issues during the period?
CoherenceHow well did the Plan align with COMESA energy policy, Agenda 2063, AfSEM, the Continental Master Plan, SDG 7 and Mission 300? Did RAERESA’s work complement or duplicate that of RERA, EREA, EAPP, SAPP and the AUC?
EffectivenessTo what extent were the expected outcomes of each goal achieved? Which guidelines, model frameworks and standards were developed, adopted by COMESA organs and domesticated by members? What enabled or constrained results?
EfficiencyWere resources used economically and on time? How did actual income and expenditure compare with the Plan’s projections? Were the Secretariat’s structure and staffing adequate for the workload?
ImpactWhat measurable change can credibly be linked to RAERESA’s work, for example in regulatory independence, cost-reflective tariffs, cross-border trade, private investment, RE and EE uptake, and consumer protection?
SustainabilityAre results and institutional gains likely to last? How far has RAERESA progressed towards predictable member funding and financial independence? How strong is member ownership?

B3. Institutional, governance and financial assessment

  1. The Consultant shall specifically assess:
  • progress against the governance model approved in the Plan, including the restructured Portfolio Committees and the transition from the interim COMESA-hosted Secretariat to an autonomous Secretariat;

  • the Secretariat’s staffing, skills mix, systems, policies and procedures relative to its mandate and workload;

  • membership growth and engagement, and the quality of member participation in RAERESA programmes;

  • the three future development options set out in the Plan (association, organisation with a Regulatory Board, or regional regulatory authority), and the institutional form best suited to RAERESA from 2027; and

  • planned versus actual income and expenditure by year and source, budget execution, compliance with membership contributions, funding dependency and resource mobilisation with development partners.

B4. Forward-looking analysis

  1. To ensure the review directly informs the new Plan, the Consultant shall:
  • carry out an updated PESTEL, SWOT and stakeholder analysis of RAERESA;

  • identify unfinished initiatives to be carried forward, revised or discontinued;

  • identify emerging priorities for 2027–2031, including at a minimum: regional market integration and EAPP–SAPP market coupling; operationalisation of the EAPP Independent Regulatory Board and a robust market operator; realignment with AfSEM; Mission 300 and national energy compacts; a regional regulatory peer review mechanism; petroleum and gas regulation; mini-grids and distributed energy; energy transition and climate finance; digitalisation and data; and regulatory capacity building, including through the proposed COMESA Energy Institute; and

  • recommend a strengthened results framework for the new Plan, with SMART indicators, baselines and targets.

B5. Methodology

  1. The review shall be participatory, use mixed methods and triangulate evidence from multiple sources. The Consultant shall propose a detailed methodology which, at a minimum, includes:
  • Inception and evaluation matrix: reconstruction of the Plan’s theory of change and results chain, and an evaluation matrix linking questions to indicators, data sources and methods;

  • Document and data review: the Strategic Plan, Business Plan, Work Programmes, annual and AGM reports, Plenary and Executive Committee decisions, audited financial statements, any mid-term review or technical audit, partner programme reports and RAERESA instruments;

  • Performance scorecard: rating of each of the 45 implementation initiatives and each strategic goal (achieved, substantially achieved, partially achieved, not achieved, no longer relevant), supported by evidence;

  • Domestication tracking: mapping of which RAERESA instruments were adopted by COMESA organs and domesticated by each member, and with what effect;

  • Stakeholder consultations: key informant interviews and an online survey of member regulators, governance organs, Secretariat staff, the COMESA Secretariat, ministries responsible for energy, EAPP, IRB, ERERA, SAPP, RERA, EREA, AFUR, AUC, AUDA-NEPAD, development partners and selected private-sector and consumer representatives;

  • Case studies: two (2) short case studies of member countries or flagship initiatives;

  • Benchmarking: comparison of RAERESA’s model, funding and results with peer regional regulatory bodies such as RERA, EREA, ERERA, ACER and the IRB-EAPP; and

  • Validation: presentation of preliminary findings to the Executive Committee and to a virtual validation workshop of members and stakeholders.

  1. The Consultant shall collect sex-disaggregated data where relevant, consider gender and social inclusion, and state data limitations and how they were addressed.

  2. DELIVERABLES

  3. The key deliverables of this assignment are:

  • an Inception Report, including the evaluation matrix, data collection tools and work-plan;

  • a Draft and a Final End-Term Review Report, with a performance scorecard of all strategic goals and implementation initiatives, financial analysis, institutional and governance assessment, lessons learned and prioritised recommendations;

  • a Strategic Inputs Paper of up to fifteen (15) pages setting out recommended strategic priorities, institutional options and a draft results framework for the Strategic Plan 2027–2031;

  • a validation workshop report and a matrix showing how stakeholder comments were addressed;

  • all raw data, survey datasets and data collection templates; and

  • a four-page executive summary and presentation materials for the RAERESA Plenary.

  1. The Final Report shall contain, at a minimum: an executive summary; background and methodology; findings by evaluation criterion; performance against each strategic goal; institutional, governance and financial assessment; lessons learned; prioritised recommendations with responsible parties; and annexes (scorecard of all initiatives, evaluation matrix, tools, list of persons consulted and documents reviewed).

  2. CONSULTANT QUALIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENTS

  3. The assignment is open to individual consultants with proven expertise in monitoring and evaluation. The consultant shall have:

  • Masters degree in Economic, Statistics, business administration, Engineering, Development Studies, and Project Management

  • demonstrable experience in monitoring and evaluation of strategic plans, programmes or institutions in the public sector, regional economic communities or international organisations;

  • at least ten (10) years’ professional experience, including at least five (5) years leading evaluations of strategic plans or programmes of public or regional institutions;

  • experience in results-based management, institutional and organisational assessments, and stakeholder consultations across several countries;

  • experience in at least two (2) referenced similar assignments on the African continent or in similar environments; and

  • the ability to commence activities immediately following conclusion of the contract and to complete the assignment within six (6) weeks.

  • demonstrated expertise in theory of change, OECD-DAC criteria, strategic planning and mixed-methods evaluation.

  • Experience with COMESA, EAC, SADC, the AU or similar regional bodies is an advantage.

  1. Experience in the energy or infrastructure sector, or with regulatory institutions, is an advantage but is not a requirement.

  2. The Consultant shall provide a list of the team members to be assigned to the Assignment (the “Proposed Team”), together with the CVs of the designated (i) Team Leader / Monitoring and Evaluation Expert; and (ii) Monitoring and Evaluation Specialist / Data Analyst (the “Designated Experts”). An individual consultant must demonstrate that he or she covers the competencies of both Designated Experts.

  3. In addition, the consultant must have the following qualifications:

  • experience working in or with regional, bilateral or multilateral organisations;

  • proven ability in research, report-writing and analysis, and capacity to deliver outputs within tight timelines;

  • strong facilitation and communication (verbal and written) skills, accuracy and attention to detail;

  • proficiency in data analysis and survey software;

  • fluency in English; working knowledge of French or Arabic will be considered an advantage; and

  • no involvement in the preparation or implementation of the Strategic Plan 2017–2026, to safeguard independence.

  1. TIMEFRAME

  2. The Assignment shall be completed within four (4) to six (6) weeks and the contract shall not exceed six (6) consecutive weeks after contract signature, with an estimated level of effort of thirty (30) working days for the full team.

  3. One (1) week from contract signature, the Consultant will prepare and submit an Inception Report. This report will define the scope and schedule of the assignment, present the evaluation matrix and the information needed, provide an outline of mitigating measures for any anticipated challenges, and propose the stakeholder engagement plan, including consultations in selected Member States and with regional bodies, bearing in mind the reporting schedule below.

  4. In the execution of the Assignment, the Consultant shall follow the suggested reporting schedule in the table below:

Title of Report/ ActivityDescriptionTimeframe for Submission
Contract Signing/Kick-off meetingVideo/audio conference involving the RAERESA Secretariat and the Consultant’s team. The Consultant will give an overview of how it plans to execute the assignment.T
Inception ReportDraft inception report presenting the understanding of the assignment, reconstructed theory of change, evaluation matrix, data collection tools, stakeholder list, countries to be consulted, risks and mitigation measures, and detailed work-plan.T + 1 week
Presentation on Inception ReportPresentation of the Inception Report to the RAERESA Secretariat in Lusaka (or virtually) and agreement on the final methodology and work-plan.T + 1 week
Progress ReportBrief update on data collection, emerging findings and any constraints, to the RAERESA Secretariat.T + 2 weeks
Draft End-Term Review ReportSubmission of the draft report, including the performance scorecard, financial analysis, institutional assessment, lessons and draft recommendations.T + 4 weeks
Validation WorkshopPresentation, for validation, of the main findings and recommendations to the RAERESA governance structures and to external stakeholders, including: RAERESA Secretariat; COMESA Secretariat Division in charge of Energy; National regulators and ministries responsible for energy; EAPP, SAPP, ERERA, RERA, EREA and AFUR; Development partners and other regional and continental bodiesT + 5 weeks
Final End-Term Review ReportSubmission of the final report incorporating comments from RAERESA and the validation workshop, with a comments-response matrix.T + 6 weeks
Raw Data and TemplatesAll raw data, survey datasets and data collection templates.T + 6 weeks
Strategic Inputs Paper and Presentation MaterialsStrategic Inputs Paper for the Strategic Plan 2027–2031, four-page executive summary and presentation for the RAERESA Plenary.T + 6 weeks
  1. Payments shall be made on approval of deliverables as follows: 20% on approval of the Inception Report; 40% on approval of the Draft Report and completion of the validation workshop; and 40% on approval of the Final Report and the Strategic Inputs Paper.

  2. REPORTING REQUIREMENTS

  3. The Assignment shall be conducted under the overall direction and supervision of the Chief Executive Officer of the RAERESA Secretariat. The Consultant will report on a day-to-day basis to a focal person designated by the Secretariat. All deliverables shall be subject to review and approval by the RAERESA Secretariat.

  4. The Consultant shall submit a proposed outline of the reports for approval by the RAERESA Secretariat. The reports should be in Times New Roman font size 12, and the Final Report should not exceed sixty (60) pages excluding annexes.

  5. The RAERESA Secretariat shall provide written comments on each deliverable within five (5) working days of receipt.

  6. All draft reports of the Consultant shall be submitted for initial review, prior to submission of the final versions, to:

Prof. Geoffrey A. Mabea

Chief Executive Officer

Regional Association of Energy Regulators for Eastern and Southern Africa (RAERESA)

Email: gaori@comesa.int

  1. All final reports are to be submitted to:

Mailing address:

Regional Association of Energy Regulators for Eastern and Southern Africa

Ben Bella Road

P O Box 30051

Lusaka

Zambia

Email: raeresa@comesa.int;

Attention:

Prof. Geoffrey A. Mabea

Chief Executive Officer

Regional Association of Energy Regulators for Eastern and Southern Africa

Email: gaori@comesa.int

  1. LANGUAGE

  2. All reports and documents will be in English.

  3. LOCATION OF THE ASSIGNMENT

  4. The assignment shall be carried out in COMESA Member States and all Consultations may be held virtually.

  5. RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE CONSULTANT

  6. The Consultant shall co-operate fully with RAERESA to complete the assignment on schedule, liaise with all relevant stakeholders, and collect and analyse information across Member States.

  7. The Consultant shall be responsible for organising interviews and surveys, the costs of its own travel and subsistence, and the facilitation of the validation workshop.

  8. All data, reports and materials produced under the assignment belong to RAERESA and shall not be used or disclosed without RAERESA’s written consent. The Consultant shall respect the confidentiality of all persons consulted.

  9. RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE RAERESA SECRETARIAT

  10. The RAERESA Secretariat will provide the Consultant with all available reports, studies, financial statements, decisions and documents relevant to this assignment.

  11. The Secretariat shall facilitate and coordinate meetings between the Consultant and member regulators, COMESA Member States and other stakeholders, and shall meet the venue costs of the validation workshop.

  12. The Secretariat shall review all reports, recommendations and other matters brought before it by the Consultant within the stipulated time, to enable the Consultant to conclude the assignment within the timeframe.

  13. SUBMISSION AND EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS

  14. Proposals shall comprise a technical proposal (cover letter and company profile with evidence of similar assignments and three references; understanding of the assignment and comments on these Terms of Reference; methodology and work-plan; team composition with working days per expert; signed CVs of not more than four pages each; and a sample of a recent strategic plan review written by the Team Leader) and a separate financial proposal (all-inclusive lump sum in US dollars, broken down into professional fees, travel, subsistence and other reimbursable costs, with taxes stated separately).

  15. Proposals will be evaluated using Quality and Cost-Based Selection (80% technical, 20% financial). Only technical proposals scoring at least eighty (80) points will have their financial proposals opened. The technical evaluation criteria are:

CriterionPoints
Experience of the consultant in similar assignments15
Understanding of the assignment and quality of methodology and work-plan35
Qualifications and experience of the Consultant25
Qualifications and experience of the M&E Specialist / Data Analyst20
Knowledge of COMESA and regional institutions in Eastern and Southern Africa5
Total100

The RAERESA Secretariat reserves the right to accept or reject any proposal and is not bound to accept the lowest-priced proposal. Experts from COMESA Member States, youth and women experts, are encouraged to apply.

Remote working and contract

Lusaka – Zambia but assignment shall be carried out virtually.

You shall be considered as a short-term consultant. The Assignment shall be completed within four (4) to six (6) weeks.

Invitation and application requirements

Dear Consultant,

The Regional Association of Energy Regulators for Eastern and Southern Africa (RAERESA) invites eligible Individual Consultants to submit Technical and Financial Proposals for the assignment:

"End-Term Review of the RAERESA Strategic Plan 2017-2026."

The assignment seeks an independent assessment of the implementation, achievements, efficiency, relevance, sustainability and impact of the Strategic Plan 2017-2026 and to generate strategic recommendations for the preparation of the Strategic Plan 2027-2031.

The detailed Terms of Reference (TOR) are attached as Section 7 of this Request for Proposals.

This procurement shall be undertaken through direct issuance of an RFP without a prior shortlisting stage. Consultants shall submit:

  1. One Technical Proposal in a sealed envelope marked "TECHNICAL PROPOSAL"; and

  2. One Financial Proposal in a separate sealed envelope marked "FINANCIAL PROPOSAL".

The two envelopes shall be enclosed in one outer envelope clearly marked:

"Proposal for End-Term Review of the RAERESA Strategic Plan 2017-2026 - Do Not Open Before Proposal Opening Time."

Interested Consultants are invited to submit proposals in accordance with the instructions contained in this RFP.

The Proposal SHALL be submitted via email to the following address: tenders@comesa.int copy procurement@comesa.int; copying DMaimbo@comesa.int

(a) Technical Proposal: one (1) original in pdf format; and

(b) Financial Proposal: one (1) original in pdf format the financial proposals MUST be password protected. The bidders shall keep their passwords to themselves until they are contacted to provide them during the financial opening meeting. FAILURE TO SUBMIT A CORRECT PASSWORD WILL LEAD TO THE FINANCIAL PROPOSAL NOT BEING OPENED.

An online option of the opening of both the Technical and Financial Proposals shall be online via Zoom or Teams

Date: 8 December 2026 at 10:30 hours local Zambian time (GMT+2**)**

Yours sincerely,

Mr Silver Mwesigwa

Head of Procurement and General Services

Attn: Daniel Maimbo

COMESA Centre

Ben Bella Road

P.O Box 30051

LUSAKA 10101

Zambia

Telephone: +260 211 2297226/29; Web: http://www.comesa.int Facsimile: +260 211 227318;

Ensure to copy :

cc. DMaimbo@comesa.int; procurement@comesa.int

SECTION 2: INSTRUCTIONS TO CONSULTANTS

ITC 1. Background

RAERESA is undertaking an End-Term Review of its Strategic Plan 2017-2026 to assess performance, institutional development, financial sustainability and strategic relevance, and to provide recommendations for the preparation of the Strategic Plan 2027-2031.

ITC 2. Procurement Method

The selection shall be undertaken through a Quality and Cost Based Selection (QCBS) method adapted for Individual Consultants.

Technical and Financial Proposals shall be submitted simultaneously in two separate sealed envelopes.

Only Financial Proposals of Consultants obtaining a minimum technical score of 80 points shall be opened and evaluated.

ITC 3. Conflict of Interest

The Consultant shall not have participated in the preparation, implementation or management of the Strategic Plan 2017-2026 and shall be free from any conflict of interest.

ITC 4. Clarifications

Any request for clarification shall be submitted by email no later than seven (7) calendar days before the proposal submission deadline.

The contact information for requesting clarifications is:

The Head of Procurement and General Services

COMESA Secretariat

Ben Bella road

Lusaka, Zambia

Email address: tenders@comesa.int copy procurement@comesa.int; copy DMaimbo@comesa.int

SECTION 3: DATA SHEET

ItemRequirement
ClientRAERESA Secretariat
AssignmentEnd-Term Review of the RAERESA Strategic Plan 2017-2026
Type of ConsultantIndividual Consultant
Proposal CurrencyUnited States Dollars (USD)
Proposal Validity90 days
Contract TypeLump Sum Contract
DurationMaximum 6 weeks
Estimated Level of Effort30 Working Days
LanguageEnglish
Submission MethodElectronic
Financial ProposalSeparate Sealed Envelope
Minimum Technical Score80 Points
Technical/Financial Weighting80:20

Full official RFP and contract forms.

Additional notes

Email separate technical and financial proposals in PDF to tenders@comesa.int and copy procurement@comesa.int and DMaimbo@comesa.int. Password-protect the financial PDF. See the full RFP for the subject line and proposal components.